I need a new grill!!

peter sherman

Well-known member
May 10, 2004
3,072
0
Fake Forest, IL
Any thoughts???
I have been a Weber charcoal guy forever. I looking for something different....
Any thoughts! If youve never used a grill don't even think about replying...
 

rovercanus

Well-known member
Apr 24, 2004
9,651
246
peter sherman said:
Any thoughts???
I have been a Weber charcoal guy forever. I looking for something different....
Any thoughts! If youve never used a grill don't even think about replying...
Consider a smoker. You can still grill on it and you can also smoke a mean tenderloin! Get a chimney to light your charcoal, you'll never need fluid again, uses 2 pieces of newspaper. You can get this stuff at your local Walmart Super Center!:p
 

BaldEagle

Well-known member
Sep 13, 2004
2,824
0
Atlanta, GA
Kavic said:
Get the Big Green Egg. Don't have one but I hear they are the sh!t.

http://backyardbbqstore.com/17200.1.55763.59737/Featured_Products/Big_Green_Egg.html

i've always heard they're a ridiculous waste of money. i use propane but only becuase i grill out all the time and charcoal takes too long for me. i dont reccommend the walmart gas grills. i think brinkman is the name. they dont cook even. any of the nicer gas grills should be fine. they're really all the same. buying them out of season is a better idea though. save big money
 

Roverlady

Well-known member
Apr 20, 2004
7,825
0
45
Shenandoah valley
We just bought a $200 Uniflame grill that is pretty basic. 3 burners plus a side burner. Cast iron grilling surface. Porcelain and steel outer surfaces. It sure beats the one we had before that was dying...nothing fancy but the steak we had last night was great!

Oh and Walter--we grilled farm-raised, grass-fed beef on our WalMart propane grill! LOL!!

We replace grills every 3 years or so, and keep it covered (actually this one will get moved to the basement in winter) so we decided not to invest a large chunk of change into it.
 

rovercanus

Well-known member
Apr 24, 2004
9,651
246
Isn't this about charcoal grills? If you're going to cook with gas may as well stay inside.
 
A

Azdiscovery

Guest
peter sherman said:
Any thoughts???
I have been a Weber charcoal guy forever. I looking for something different....
Any thoughts! If youve never used a grill don't even think about replying...
:banghead: :smilelol: Can I run the grill in front???:smilelol: :banghead:
 

kennith

Well-known member
Apr 22, 2004
10,891
172
North Carolina
Make sure whatever you get is ALL stainless. Brass burners are good, and heavy cast iron enclosures are good, but anything else, and I mean anything, ought to be proper stainless. Otherwise it will rust all to hell. Someone gave me a grill, it was a 3,000 dollar grill. They moved and the thing wouldn't fit in their new place. It has a rust problem, and it is too big to heat up properly. You want something just barely big enough for you, and something that won't rust out.

Aluminum isn't great for an enclosure, but it's better than sheetmetal. Iron is best, but very few manufacturers make the iron enclosures with the good stuff elsewhere. Well sealed stainless enclosures can work fine, but you don't want them too large, as they can't hold the heat after you open it.

Nevermind the brand so much, what you need is something that won't crap out. I like the fake Jenn Airs in Lowes for a solid stainless grill, but they are expensive. Find something that is built like a rock.

A good old charcoal weber is great, but they need to be well taken care of. Still, you will be hard pressed to find something that will cook as easily.

Above all, you want something that will really crank the heat. Don't go too big unless you go charcoal. Don't get one with large voids that lose heat.

Cheers,

Kennith
 

Steve

Well-known member
Apr 20, 2004
1,395
0
Eastern Shore of MD
I bought a Weber Summit Platinum D6 (6 burner) last year and love it. I used it through the Winter.
 

Attachments

  • 41B3Q0DWJSL__AA280_.jpg
    41B3Q0DWJSL__AA280_.jpg
    9.5 KB · Views: 12

Roverlady

Well-known member
Apr 20, 2004
7,825
0
45
Shenandoah valley
If you were talking only about charcoal--sorry for my interjection.

We have decided to use our old propane grill as a backup for charcoal. The bowl, etc is still in decent shape, but the ignition switch broke and so did one of the burner controls. Anyone ever done this or are we just turning junk into junk?
 

antichrist

Well-known member
Sep 7, 2004
8,208
0
68
Atlanta, GA
Why not stick with something that works? Weber. This is my setup, simple but it works.
 

Attachments

  • onetouchSilver_hero.jpg
    onetouchSilver_hero.jpg
    7.5 KB · Views: 6
  • pine_cone.jpg
    pine_cone.jpg
    5 KB · Views: 6
  • charcoal.jpg
    charcoal.jpg
    4.1 KB · Views: 10

jackp

Well-known member
Dec 11, 2005
368
0
Forest, VA
www.bikesunlimited.com
TreyKramer said:

Trey: That's hilarous! BTW - did you decide on a mountain bike?



Grill recommendation is Weber for either gas or charcoal.

I've owned the same Weber gas grill for the last 15+ years. I've had to replace the porcelain cooking grids and the 'flavorizer bars' that they put in the bottom to distribute the heat twice (they are available in stainless, but I've never used them). The original ignitor is still working! The nicest part of the Weber design (on their bigger grills) is the way the burners are arranged. There are 3, running the width of the grill casting - front, middle and back. This enables you to really control the cooking temperature and do a great job of 'indirect' cooking, where you want to provide heat/flame, but not directly underneath - like a ham or turkey that you might want to cook for hours w/o any heat directly underneath, which can dry out the meat or cause flare-ups. When doing this, I use the front and back burner, with the middle burner off, or on a low temperature. Weber's also get hot enough with the direct heat to sear or blacken meats if you want to.

I've been very pleased with mine and use it 2-3 times per week in the summer and maybe once a month in the winter. 15+ years and still going strong.

PS - I love my gas grill, and people who sell gas grills will say the flavor from grilling comes from the effect of the juices from the meat hitting the hot lava rock (or whatever the manufacturer uses), and this smoke in turn flavors the meat. Maybe.....
IMO - Charcoal grills still have the best flavor hands down - I just prefer the convenience of gas.
 
Last edited:

apg

Well-known member
Dec 28, 2004
3,019
0
East Virginia
antichrist said:
Why not stick with something that works? Weber. This is my setup, simple but it works.

There's a Weber model that's the best of both worlds. It has a 5# propane tank to start the fire, but you cook with charcoal. The tank last two or more years.

Charcoal is the only way to go in my book, especially if you want to smoke food with mesquite chips or other hardwoods. And use *real* charcoal, not that brickette crap held together with starch and powdered coal. :ack: