You should judge a supplier on price and performance. Giving a shit about someone's message board posts just demonstrates your own shallowness.
My quantitative experience with DAP -- I bought a steering guard and a diff guard. Good price, quick shipping, good packing, good quality product.
I've had similar experiences with Rovers North, Atlantic British, British Pacific, Expedition Exchange, Rovertym, Paul Grant, Hellroaring, Rock Ware, Viking Offroad, and other suppliers this board probably doesn't know.
I think you pretty much get what you give. You get your panties in a knot, you're asking to be disappointed.