Benelli?s are super nice but not needed here I*t* sounds like. I have one and wouldn?t recommend to someone who isn?t a gun snob (I.e i assume you?re not, that?s why you?re posting here). I also shoot an A5 Browning and an O/U Browning Citori. Haven?t looked at costs lately so they may be out. Look for a used one, guns are like bikes and Rovers, someone?s always selling to get something else. If I had to pick between those, Id chose the A5 simply because you said you also want to dove hunt. If you?re mostly shooting Sporting clays, over /under without a doubt so you can use different chokes.