Anderson/Goodyear Fucked up my lugs!

rob mellor

Well-known member
Mar 28, 2006
154
0
44
syracuse UT
I ran on my lunch break to get my tires rotated cause I dont have time to do it my self right now, boy did I learn my lesson. The kid must have not had the right size socket cause my lugs on all 4 wheels are fucked up. The covers are all dented up. It looks like some one hit each lug on every side with a screw driver. One even has a hole in the top where they stabed a screw driver through it to pry the cover off.

Then the service manager tried telling me that they had to damage them cause the shop that installed the tires over torqued them and they couldn't get them off. Even over torqued with the right size socket it wouldn't dent the hell out of the cover! Then he said that the covers are suppose to be removable to take the lugs on/off then put the covers back on. So if that's his excuse then why didn't they take em off? 2 of them wouldn't even stay on so he hit the sides with a screw driver until it was dented so much that the dents lined up with the groove on the lug and held the cover on. Then tried to convince me that since all of the rest had these similar dents on every side (no shit cause your guy used the wrong socket on every lug) that's that's how they were designed to stay on the lug. The spare lugs, which they didn't touch, look normal "but that's cause the spare has never had a tool on it" he claims. I watched the guy at another shop put it on with the impact and they are fine cause he used a 27mm socket!

Then the service manager told me that I couldn't be in the shop while they were working on it, fine I understand that for insurance reasons. So I stood out side the over head door. Then 15 min later he asks me if I work on computers, I told him no I work on F-16's then he sais, because you are making my guys nervous watching them like when some one is watching over your shoulder on the computer. Go have a seat in the waiting room and my guys will take care of it for you. I have quality watching me do my job every day, if his mechanics suck so bad that they cant have a customer BS and talk shop with them while they work that's pretty bad. I think they just didn't want me watching while they fucked it up. Plus they had already tried to drive it out once and had "forgotten" to do several items on the ticket, which I'm sure I still would have been charged for.

Thanks for letting me rant and rave Dweb. He told me to talk to the place that installed the tires and over torqued them because it was their fault they had to mess up my lugs. Unfortunatly lunch was over, but round 2 is on after work, these jerk off's should replace all 20 lugs!
 
M

Mudquest

Guest
What a nightmare. I just had five new tires put on at a local Firestone facility, and they did a wonderfull job. Granted, I requested manual wrenching only because of all the headaches possible with an incorrectly sized socket head.

Never the less, this shop fucked up all your lugs and should replace them accordingly. I wouldn't take any crappy excuses from them at all. That's lame.

Best of luck. Keep swinging.
 

nosivad_bor

Well-known member
Mar 27, 2004
6,061
64
Pittsburgh, PA
they didnt have to damage a thing, they should have told you after the first one that they will have to fuck them up to get them off and let you decide if you want them to go ahead.

Time to be Superfly TNT guns of Navarone
 

rob mellor

Well-known member
Mar 28, 2006
154
0
44
syracuse UT
I would have gladly taken my buisness some where else if they had simply said "we don't have the right tools to do this correctly." I can respect that and they probably wouldn't have lost me, and every one I knows buisness. It was the Anderson in Layton UT on Antelope Dr.

It use to be a good shop, there was a guy there with a D1, he would always wrench for me when I brought it in. But he left and so have I after this now!
 
Last edited:
B

BODBR01

Guest
What a mess. I always INSIST they torque manually. I had one shop use a 12 point impact socket and screwed one up, and after I had them buy the $21 lug nut; they always torque now. The shop had never saw lugs with the covers on them. A 6 pt socket is a must!

I have since bought several replacements (on this site) and replaced the ones that got hosed up in the past. They should have stopped and asked you before screwing the whole show up...
 

pjkbrit

Well-known member
Apr 23, 2004
542
0
here we go...another thread that re-affirms doing as much as you can yourself...anyhow...this one should be simple...the shop replaces the lugs...period.
They did not have the right tool and now it's all a story!!
BTW...I use a long bar with the right size 6 point built in socket that I bought back in Britain for my then 1983 Range Rover. You can borrow it to hit the service manager with if he baulks at replacing the lugs he screwed up for you!
 
C

CoyGlasscock

Guest
Get a 6 point 27mm impact socket and keep in your glove compartment. That way the correct tool is always in the same place as the wheels.
 

alex

Well-known member
Apr 29, 2004
2,310
0
Libertyville, IL
way back in the day when my disco was only a year old or so, a tire shop did this to my lug nuts. I brought it back, showed the manager, and they replaced them all with no hassle at all. You're dealing with a poorly run business, unfortunately.
 

JamesWyatt

Well-known member
Apr 10, 2005
1,640
0
Allen, TX
discoweb.org
alex said:
way back in the day when my disco was only a year old or so, a tire shop did this to my lug nuts. I brought it back, showed the manager, and they replaced them all with no hassle at all. You're dealing with a poorly run business, unfortunately.

X2. Discount tire replaced ALL of mine.

Lesson learned.